Arne Charter Schools Duncan Education Industry Privatization Race to the Top Testing

Rick Hess: Arne Duncan is Still Clueless

Interesting essay samples and examples on:

Rick Hess of the American Enterprise Institute reviewed Arne Duncan’s memoir about his seven years as Secretary of Education and concludes that Arne seemed to learn nothing from the experience.

Rick was not impressed.

When Arne Duncan was named the ninth U.S. secretary of education in early 2009, the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) had shown a decade of substantial growth, efforts to launch the Common Core and reform teacher evaluation were getting under way with ample support and little opposition, and education seemed a bipartisan bright spot in an increasingly polarized political climate.

Seven years later, when Duncan stepped down, NAEP scores had stagnated, the Common Core was a poisoned brand, research on new teacher-evaluation systems painted a picture of failure, and it was hard to find anyone who would still argue that education reform was a bipartisan cause. It would be ludicrous to say any of this was Duncan’s “fault,” but it’s fair to say that his self-certitude, expansive view of his office’s role, and impatience with his critics helped bring the great school-reform crackup to pass.

Now, Duncan has written a book about his years in education. It could have been a meditation on why things went awry, what he’s learned, and how all this should inform school improvement in the years ahead. That would have been a book well worth reading. Or Duncan might have really taken on the skeptics, answering their strongest criticisms and explaining why the path he chose was the best way forward. Instead, Duncan has opted to pen a breezy exercise in straw men and self-congratulation, while taking credit for “chang[ing] the education landscape in America.” The narrative follows Duncan from his time as a Chicago schools central-office staffer, to his tenure as superintendent in Chicago, to his service in Washington during the early years of President Barack Obama’s first term (skipping the second half of Duncan’s time in Washington), before closing with his thoughts on gun violence and an eight-point education agenda.

Throughout, Duncan comes across as a nice, extraordinarily confident guy who really likes basketball and has no doubts about how to fix schools or second thoughts about his time in Washington.

I had exactly that impression when I met Arne in 2009 and urged him not to follow in the same punitive path as NCLB. What a very nice guy! How tall he is! He took notes. But I don’t think he remembered or cared about anything I said.

Related posts

Andrea Gabor: Dark Money Floods into Massachusetts to Expand Charters


Congratulations to Brian and Cindy Malone! Their film, “Education Inc.,” Won a Heartland Emmy Award


Arizona May Revise Phony School Letter Grades, and They Will Still Be Phony


Rebellion at Amistad High: Students Walk Out


Tom Ultican: California School Administrators Endorse Favorite of Billionaire Boys Club


New York: Kids as Guinea Pigs for Testing Company


Did Texas Parents Get Fooled?


Florida: Palm Beach Post Urges School Board to Join the Lawsuit Against Horrendous HB 7069


Will Los Angeles School Board Race Be Most Expensive in History?


Leave a Comment