Charter Schools Florida Hoax National Education Policy Center

National Education Policy Center: Florida Claims About Charter Schools Are Meaningless

Interesting essay samples and examples on:

BOULDER, CO (June 18, 2019) – The Florida Department of Education recently published a report consisting almost entirely of simple graphs comparing achievement levels, achievement gaps, and achievement gains on statewide tests among charter school students to those among traditional public school students. The Department’s press release touted the report as showing that the state’s “charter school students consistently outperform their peers in traditional public schools.”

The release also quotes Florida’s Education Commissioner, asserting that the “report provides further evidence that [school choice policies] are right for Florida” and that there’s “no denying that choice works.” The press release’s spin was then echoed in pieces published/broadcast by several television stationsnewspapers, and online outlets.

Yet simple comparisons such as those in this report reveal very little about the relative effectiveness of charter schools. Robert Bifulco of Syracuse University, reviewed Student Achievement in Florida’s Charter Schools: A Comparison of the Performance of Charter School Students with Traditional Public School Students, and found it to be of extremely limited use.

Beyond the odd exercise of counting the number of comparisons that appear favorable to charter schools, the report offers no discussion. The comparisons are not even explained. The fact that the report merely presents comparisons required by law without putting any policy “spin” on them might be considered a virtue. But the danger is that such reports can (and do) encourage erroneous conclusions.

At the very least, Professor Bifulco believes, the report should have clarified the purposes of its comparisons and cautioned the reader against drawing unwarranted and potentially harmful conclusions.

Find the review, by Robert Bifulco, at:

Find Student Achievement in Florida’s Charter Schools: A Comparison of the Performance of Charter School Students with Traditional Public School Students, published by the Florida Department of Education, at:

Related posts

Chicago: Dollars for Teachers, Milliions for Charter Operator


Wayne Au: Overturning Washington State’s Charter Law, Based on ALEC Model, Is a Victory for Public Schools Everywhere


Tom Ultican: How the Destroy Public Education Movement Destroyed the Public Schools of Kansas City


PBS Explains Why It Ran a Pro-Privatization Series


In Response to My Article, a Truly Stupid Defense Of Detroit Charters


Valerie Strauss: Betsy DeVos Allies Herself with Margaret Thatcher


Tom Ultican on Philadelphia, Another School Choice Failure


John Thompson: Did We Ever Disagree? He Says We Did.


A Note Written by a Teacher at Success Academy Who Quit


Leave a Comment