Interesting essay samples and examples on:
Peter Greenewould eliminate public schools, thus wiping out one of our nation’s most democratic institutions.
State Senator Del Marsh proposed this week the “ultimate” school choice bill,(SB140) a super-education savings account. But that’s not what it really is.
This is— every Alabama family gets every cent the state would have spent on educating their child (about $6,300 last year) and they can use it to pay for educational whatever–public school, home school, private school, tutoring, online classes, whatever.
is a longtime champion of disinvestment in Alabama public ed, having pushed charters and charter expansion in previous years (he also co-sponsored a bill to make bribery of legislators by lobbyists legal).
This is a big deal, a bill that changes the rules for education in an entire state, but coverage so far has been light (the bill was supposedly going to be filed yesterday) and details.
One early complaint is that the bill would cost the state about $420 billion in education funds.Army Marlowe also called out the bill for its lack of transparency and its generosity to private operators:Senator Marsh’s “Parent’s Choice Bill” should be called exactly what it is – “No Vendor Left Behind “ – a shell game of a voucher program to divert money from Alabama’s community schools. There is a complete lack of transparency regarding this egregious bill by rushing it through committee this week. Regardless of whether Senators have been given the opportunity to study the bill, by filing it this week and expecting it to not only be in committee, but to be voted out of a committee is mind blowing. A bill of this magnitude that would result in more than $420 million cut from the Education Trust Fund rushed through committee without the opportunity for at least a week of scrutiny by the public and the media makes you wonder why Sen. Marsh is in such a hurry to move this bill.Yes, this bill would eat a ton of taxpayer dollars, and yes it would gut the public education system in Alabama. There is one other huge effect that comes with voucher-style bills that seems to be rarely discussed–it ends the state’s involvement with and support of its children.
In aneducation lab reporter Trish Powell Crain points out that this is bigger than charters or vouchers. “It’s the ultimate ‘here, take the money and parents, you go decide how you want to spend this money to educate your child.’”
Yes. “We’ve given you a check, and we hereby wash our hands of the whole education thing.” The ultimate form of voucher is not about empowering parents. It’s not even about making vendors a bunch of money. It’s about getting the state out of the education business, about cutting parents and children loose. It’s about ending the collective commitment to and responsibility for educating the next generations.