Accountability Andrew Carmen Cuomo Farina New York City Teacher Evaluations

NYC: Farina Criticizes Cuomo for Teacher Evaluation Proposal

Interesting essay samples and examples on:

At a hearing in Albany, NYC Chancellor Carmen Farina disagreed bluntly with Governor Cuomo ‘s proposal to base 50% of teacher evaluations on student test scores and 35% on the judgement of independent evaluators, people from outside the school.

“I think 50 percent based on tests is too much,” Ms. Fariña told state legislators at a budget hearing on Tuesday, in comments that were echoed by representatives of other large school districts. “We need a human touch any time we evaluate anyone for anything.”

She also objective to the “independent evaluators.”

“Ms. Fariña said that teachers needed to be observed over time, watched for things like whether they engaged with parents or gave special attention to students who needed extra help, and that “flybys” could not replace that.”

And she added:

“There’s so many other things,” Fariña said. “I was a teacher for more than 20 years and if I was only measured in test scores, that would only have been a little bit of my work…..”

“I absolutely believe that holding teachers accountable only on test scores and outside evaluators is not a good idea,” Fariña said in response to questions about Cuomo’s plan.

Cuomo told the Buffalo News that:

“The test is really the only easy answer because it is objective numerical data and it was the same test with the same demographic,” Cuomo told a group of reporters and editors from The Buffalo News on Tuesday.”

The difference between Farina and Cuomo is that she has been a teacher, a principal, a superintendent, and now Chancellor. She is a veteran educator who knows teaching and learning. Cuomo has no experience in education but insists that he knows how teachers should be evaluated.

It is clear that he is over his head. He doesn’t know that most teachers don’t teach tested subjects. How does he propose to evaluate teachers of the arts, physical education, foreign languages, teachers of K-2, and high school teachers. It is a shame that he is unfamiliar with the extensive research on test-based accountability and VAM.

Related posts

Steven Singer: Accountability Begins at the Top, not in the Classroom


Carol Burris: SUNY’s Absurd Proposal to Allow Charters to Certify Their Own Teachers


Arizona: New Study Finds that Three-Quarters of Charters Are Financially Mismanaged


Thomas Ultican: What Is the Center for Reinventing Public Education?


Tom Ultican: How the Billionaires Took Control of an Impoverished District in New Jersey


Perdido Street Blogger: 45% of Buffalo Teacher Ratings Were Inaccurate


The Terror of the Impeachment Trial


Jan Resseger: Why I Will Not Vote for Michael Bloomberg for President


Palm Beach County: Massive Data Breach!


Leave a Comment