Corporate Reformers Scandals Fraud and Hoaxes Stand for Children StudentsFirst

Is It Really “All About the Kids?”

Interesting essay samples and examples on:

This teacher blogger says that the worst line invented by the reformers‘ PR team is “It’s all about the kids,” which seems to imply that teachers don’t care about their students. Right up there among toxic and accusatory lines are “Students First” and “Students Matter.” I would add “Children First” as another insulting trope. Also “Stand for Children,” which critics call “Stand on Children.” All imply that teachers have been putting their own interests first, or they don’t think children matter.



Who really, truly cares about the kids? Not their teachers, not their parents, but billionaires, hedge-fund managers, entrepreneurs, politicians.



This insulting rhetoric trips lightly off the tongues of reformers, along with assertions of wanting “to save poor kids from failing schools” by closing their school and handing the kids over to privatizers.



“Raging Horse” saw this teacher-bashing reach the height of absurdity or the depths of slime in a statement made by Carmen Arroyo, a member of the New York State Assembly, defending Cuomo’s test-based teacher evaluation plan.



She said:



“Those teachers that [sic] are responsible and are doing their job, those teachers that [sic] sacrifice their families and themselves for the children they serve are going to be protected. Those that are not good, better get a job at McDonalds…..”



Raging Horse blogger writes:



“Any system that demands the sacrifice of a person’s family is deranged and any public official who demands such is unfit for public office. Any people who stand for such deserve what they get.”

Related posts

CSPAN Book TV: My Conversation about SLAYING GOLIATHwith Susan Solomon in San Francisco: FULL VERSION


A Progress Report from the Network for Public Education


Samuel Abrams Responds to Barron’s Takedown of His Book and the Editor Makes a Snarky Comment


School Choice: Grounded in Racism, Reinvented by the Radical Right


Washington Monthly: What Would “Populism with a Brain” Look Like?


Out of Control: The Systematic Disenfranchisement of African-American and Latino Communities Through School Takeovers


Louisiana: John White Wants to Keep His Job; Dem Candidate; “No Way”


Thomas Ultican: Who Is Behind the Corporate Reform Agenda in Dallas?


No-Excuses Charter Chain Fires Principal for Caring About Children and Teachers


Leave a Comment