Accountability Charter Schools Corporate Reformers Discipline Education Industry Harlem Success Academy Privatization Standardized Testing

Gary Rubinstein Writes a Letter to the Mega-Donors Who Support Success Academy: “You’ve Been Scammed!”

Interesting essay samples and examples on:

Gary Rubinstein notes that Eva Moskowitz’s Success Academy charter chain has been a “success” in attracting huge donations from hedge fund managers. Gary was a charter member of Teach for America and a part of the Reform world. But he got woke in 2010 at the TFA 20th anniversary celebration. He just can’t stand lies and boasting; honesty is in his DNA.

In this post, he warns that the big donors are being scammed. They believe what the PR department of Success Academy tells them. It has an obvious interest in putting out information that portrays the chain as a miracle, a miracle that can be easily copied by others. But as he shows, no one has been able to reproduce Success Academy’s test scores, and attention should be paid to how those test scores are generated.

Rubinstein has made a reputation as a miracle-buster. In this post, he does it again.

Dear Seven Digit Success Academy Donor,

Obviously if you have seven (or eight!) figures to donate to Success Academy, you are a person who does not easily fall for scams. But this time, I’m afraid you did.

There are really only two possibilities: Either Success Academy is the greatest miracle in the history of education — or the greatest Hoax…

If Success Academy is hiding some secret methods that could be scaled around the country so that other schools could achieve results even in the same ballpark, these methods would be worth billions of dollars to Eva Moskowitz. If she is for real, she has found the equivalent of Ponce De Leon’s famed fountain of youth…

I assume you were inspired by the mind-blowing statistics from Success Academy’s PR department. I assume you were impressed by the way that their 3rd grade through 8th grade test scores would make them the top district in New York State. You assume that their methods can be replicated, but no other charter school in the state has done so…

Success Academy is built on a foundation of lies and it is only a matter of time before it comes crumbling down.

Related posts

The Curious Connection Between Paul Vallas and Illinois Governor Bruce Rauner, as Told by Dan Mihapolous and Mike Klonsky


TeacherKen Writes a Letter to President and Mrs. Obama (LINK ADDED)


Sarah Lahm: $290,000 Flows to Minneapolis School Board Race


Texas: Senate Education Committee Guts Local Control of Schools


San Antonio: Charter Leader Accused of Massive Theft from School


Nonprofit Quarterly: Some Very Expensive Lessons for Billionaire School Reformers


A Certified Teacher-Librarian Expresses Sympathy for Dr. John King


Ohio: LeBron James’ School Demonstrates that Money and Kindness Matter


Arthur Camins: Have We Lost the Capacity for Collective Action?


Leave a Comment