Accountability Arts Education Civil Rights Class size Education Industry Funding Testing

Brian Jones: “Deepen the Conversation” about Standardized Testing and Civil Rights

Interesting essay samples and examples on: https://essays.io/dissertation-examples-samples/

Brian Jones, a former teacher in the New York City public schools, is currently a doctoral student at the City University of New York. He here explains a conundrum: Many black parents think that choice and standardized tests are good for their children, despite abundant evidence to the contrary. How should he reason with those who disagree? He focuses here on the issue of standardized testing, which compels schools–especially those serving poor and minority students–to divert time and resources to testing and test preparation, thus leaving less time for the arts and other subjects that are essential ingredients of a good education. In his experience, it is best not to argue with parents who have been persuaded by the “reformer” claims, but to listen respectfully and to “deepen the conversation,” a term he learned from Chicago teacher Xian Barrett.

 

Jones writes:

 

Likewise, when we deepen the conversation about standardized testing, we usually discover that parents and educators want similar things for our children. If standardized tests are widely and loudly touted as an antiracist measure of opportunity and fairness, some parents who are desperately searching for some measure of fairness for their children might latch onto that. Those of us who are opposed to high-stakes standardized testing shouldn’t moralize with people, or disparage their viewpoints or their experience. Rather, we have to validate their experience and find a way to deepen the conversation.

 

In my mind, we can find a lot of common ground on resources and curriculum. Of course, I think teacher training is important. It is absolutely essential that teachers be trained to respect the languages, cultures, and viewpoints of students and their families—and engage them in the learning process. But this should never lead us away from demanding the kind of educational redistribution that this country refuses to take seriously. My experience as a student has convinced me that resources are central. On scholarship, I attended an all-boys’ private high school. As one of the few students of color (let alone black students), did I experience racism and prejudice? Absolutely. However, there are aspects of my education that I wouldn’t trade for anything—the opportunity to read whole novels and discuss them in small classes, the opportunity to participate in several sports teams, to put on plays, to engage in organized debates, and to practice giving speeches. If, for my own child, I had to choose between an amazingly well-resourced school with a fabulously rich curriculum staffed with some prejudiced teachers, on the one hand, and a resource-starved school with progressive, antiracist educators who were forced to teach out of test-prep workbooks on the other, I hate to say it, but I would choose the resources every time.

 

Our society is currently spending untold sums to create more tests, more data systems, more test preparation materials, ad nauseam. And then they have the audacity to tell us that these are antiracist measures! Of course, all this focus on testing is a huge market opportunity for the private companies that provide all these services and materials. What is never under serious consideration is the idea that we could take all those same millions of dollars and create for all children the kind of cozy, relaxed, child-centered teaching and learning conditions that wealthy kids already enjoy.

Related posts

When I Introduced Senator Sanders At UTLA Leadership Conference

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

Teacher: My Nightmare Year in a Charter School

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

NYC: Emergency Rally Thursday at Noon

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

Sara Stevenson: What Do State Tests Really Cost?

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

Jersey Jazzman: The Facts About Charter Schools in Newark

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

Florida: Corporate Education Reform Trial Started Today!

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

Jeff Bryant on the Charter Gravy Train Report from NEPC

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

“Chicago Magazine” on the Rise and Fall of Juan Rangel

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

Join the Rally on Long Island on March 9!

V4tgDpeDBhQGUBa7

Leave a Comment